Alternatives to

C

Black Cat Peanut Butter

dry food · cats · 57/100 · Average

Looking for an alternative to Black Cat Peanut Butter? Here are dry food products for cats that PetFoodRate grades higher, and cheaper options for the same use.

In short

The best-rated alternative to Black Cat Peanut Butter in our database is Orijen Cat & Kitten (94/100, grade A), versus Black Cat Peanut Butter's 57/100. All graded on the same independent A-E method, no sponsored brands.

By Theo Blanchard · reviewed by Max Kowalski · updated June 2026 · independent grading, no sponsorship

Back to product page

Black Cat Peanut Butter vs its best alternative

CriterionBlack Cat Peanut ButterOrijen Cat & Kitten
Overall gradeC 57/100A 94/100
Protein qualityDA
Nutritional balanceCA
Few undesirablesBA
Ingredient transparencyCA
Species fitDA
Crude protein23%40%
Protein (dry matter)25.3%44.4%
Estimated carbs20%19%
First ingredientAdded sugarsFresh chicken

Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 40% crude protein vs 23%.

Orijen Cat & Kitten outscores 100% of dry food for cats in our database.

8 better-graded alternatives

  1. #1AOrijenCat & Kitten94/100+37Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 40% crude protein vs 23%.
  2. #2AOrijenSix Fish Cat92/100+35Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 40% crude protein vs 23%.
  3. #3AApplawsKitten90/100+33Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 38% crude protein vs 23%.
  4. #4AAcanaFirst Feast Kitten89/100+32Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 37% crude protein vs 23%.
  5. #5AAcanaHomestead Harvest Cat88/100+31Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 37% crude protein vs 23%.
  6. #6AUltra Premium DirectCroquettes Chat Adulte Saumon88/100+31Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 35% crude protein vs 23%.
  7. #7AAcanaIndoor Entrée Cat88/100+31Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 37% crude protein vs 23%.
  8. #8AZiggyCroquettes Chat Stérilisé Sans Céréales Saumon87/100+30Wins on protein quality and nutritional balance ; 28% crude protein vs 23%.

Other food types for cats

  1. #1AThriveProReward 100% Poulet90/100treats
  2. #2AApplawsNatural Tuna Fillet87/100wet food
  3. #3AZIWI PeakAir-Dried Mackerel Lamb Cat86/100raw food
  4. #4ALily\'s KitchenTerrine au Saumon85/100wet food
  5. #5BTiki CatAloha Friends Tuna & Pumpkin84/100wet food
  6. #6BEdgard & CooperPâtée Chat Adulte Saumon84/100wet food

Keep exploring

All Black Cat productsSee the average score and rangeBest dry food for catsTop 10 by PetFoodRateCompare 2 productsSide by side, grade by grade

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Black Cat Peanut Butter?

In our database it's Orijen Cat & Kitten, scoring 94/100 (A) versus Black Cat Peanut Butter's 57/100, among dry food for cats. 8 better-graded alternatives are listed above.

Is there a cheaper alternative to Black Cat Peanut Butter?

Cheaper-per-kg options for the same use are listed in the dedicated section on this page whenever our database has them.

Why switch from Black Cat Peanut Butter?

Black Cat Peanut Butter scores 57/100 (C) on our A-E method. Buyers look for an alternative to get higher protein quality, fewer undesirables, better transparency, or a better species fit. Our grading is independent with no sponsorship.