Rankings/Dogs/Beneful

Beneful

Originals with Real Beef

Dogs · kibble · 13.6 kg

D

Overall score41/100· Poor

Summary

Mainstream Purina US kibble, very cheap. Corn first, unidentified by-products, visible colorants. Misleading 'real beef' marketing.

Sub-scores

DProteins
CNutrition balance
DUndesirables
ETransparency
BSpecies adaptability

Composition analysed

Corn, meat by-products, wheat, beef (4%), sugars, colorants, vitamins

  1. CCorncereal
  2. DProcessed animal proteinsprotein
  3. CWheatcereal
  4. BBeef4%protein
  5. EAdded sugarsproblematic additive
  6. EColorants (E102, E110, E124, E129)problematic additive

Nutritional analysis

Crude protein
25%
Crude fat
14%
Ash
7%
Fibre
4%
Moisture
12%

Strengths

    Weaknesses

    • First ingredient is a cereal, not a named meat
    • Contains undesirable ingredients
    • Limited composition transparency

    Similar alternatives

    User reviews

    Loading reviews...

    Leave a review for this product

    Your review will be verified before publication. No personal data is shared.

    Frequently asked questions

    What score does Beneful Originals with Real Beef get?

    Beneful Originals with Real Beef gets a grade of D (41/100), i.e. "poor", on the PetFoodRate A to E scale. The grade combines five axes: protein quality, nutritional balance, absence of undesirable ingredients, labelling transparency and species suitability.

    What are the strengths and weaknesses of Beneful Originals with Real Beef?

    Weaknesses: First ingredient is a cereal, not a named meat, Contains undesirable ingredients, Limited composition transparency.

    Is Beneful Originals with Real Beef a good fit for dogs?

    On species suitability, this product scores B. It is broadly suited to the needs of dogs, as part of a balanced diet.

    How does PetFoodRate rate dry food?

    PetFoodRate grades every product from A to E independently and deterministically, from the ingredient list and analytical constituents, with no sponsored brands and no influence from affiliate links.